10 REASONS WHY IT'S GREAT TO BE BRITISH
The following speech, making the case for the United Kingdom, by Alistair McConnachie at Hothorpe Hall, Theddingworth, Leicestershire, on Tuesday 22nd July 2008, was published in the July 2008 edition of Sovereignty. It was posted on the web in February 2012.
The concern of us all here is that the SNP do not manage to break up our Union, and indeed break up our country, Great Britain.
That's what I want to talk about today.
I hesitate to talk about the "rise" of the SNP.
However, there is a lot of "noise" generated by that tendency, and the noisy can tend to dominate any political culture, just like they can dominate any social circle.
In both cases, they don't have to be talking sense for them to be heard and to tend to get their way!
So we have a very noisy "First Minister" in Alex Salmond. His raison d'etre requires that he ferment tension between Scotland and England. That's very unfortunate, but thankfully neither he nor his party is necessarily going to be there in the long-term.
However, his plan is to hold a referendum on "independence". At any such referendum, the politics of "identity" is likely to play a major role. That is to say, those of us who identify as British and Scottish are more likely to vote for unity than those who identify only as Scottish, and so our task, if we are to win, is to promote the British identity and show how it can also incorporate our Scottishness.
So, with that thought in mind, let me give you 10 Reasons Why it's Great to be British! I should emphasise, this list is not exhaustive! It's 10 reasons which occurred to me off the top of my head, and we want to expand this list when we hear from the people out there with more good reasons!
1- It is Great to be British because it is better to belong to 4 countries than only one.
It's great to go on holiday to another part of Britain and say, "This is my country too".
Those who identify only with Scotland, or England, or only one part of our Islands, don't have that psychological feeling, and can't share that joy. Scotland and England are different countries, but uniquely we are blessed by the fact that we are also part of the same country - Great Britain. I don't want to have to look on England as a foreign country!
2- It is Great to be British because it is great to identify with all the other people of the British Isles.
To identify with their achievements, their joy, their sadness. Thus a British Scot can delight and rejoice in the success of the English football or rugby team - or share the sadness of its loss - because it represents an extension of his or her own national identity in the world.
An identity which allows one to automatically bond with the other 60 million people who are living in the same islands as oneself is a valuable identity!
3- It is Great to be British because it is an embracing and inclusive identity with room for other identities within.
For example, a British identity allows for an English, Irish, Scottish or Welsh identity to exist within the wider identity - without compromising or stifling the other identity.
Our sense of Englishness, or Irishness, or Scottishness, or Welshness finds expression within a wider Britishness - through embracing a wider unity not a narrow separatism. Our identities complement, not contradict, each other.
We, as English or Scots respect the traditions of our particular nations, but we also respect our collective, shared traditions united within the embracing concept of Britain and our Britishness.
4- It is Great to be British because it is an expansive identity.
That is, it widens one's horizons. It prevents a parochial, narrow-minded attitude. It keeps us focused on the big picture of Britain.
You know, one of the aims of the separatists - and this indicates their narrow mindedness - is to establish a Scottish TV news broadcast at 6pm. That is to say, they want to replace the 6pm BBC News from around Britain with "the Scottish Six" as they call it. I cannot think of anything more likely to narrow the field of vision of the Scots and develop a narrow-minded parochialism than the idea that we all sit around watching the "Scottish Six" report on a Scottish cat, stuck up a Scottish tree, somewhere in Scotland! It is that sort of narrowness of vision which we are fighting against, and which we can challenge and change!
5- It is Great to be British because it means you don't have to choose between different identities.
For example, a Scot can marry an Englishwoman and the child will have a ready-made identity - the child doesn't have to choose between being English or being Scottish, but has an automatic identity - British.
You know, the separatists will say stupid things like, "There is no such thing as 'Britishness'."
Well, only to the extent that there is no definitive definition of Britishness. However, the exact same thing could be said about "Englishness", "Irishness" (especially!), "Scottishness", or "Welshness" - all of these identities contain similarities, differences, diversities, inconsistencies and ambiguities. Yet Britishness unites them all.
The separatists who like to say, "There is no such thing as 'Britishness'" are simply trying to make a statement of politics rather than a statement of fact. The political aim being to attempt to de-construct and de-legitimise the idea of a political order based upon the identity. If you can pretend the identity does not exist then you can more easily try to de-construct the political order.
6- It is Great to be British because each of us is heir to a rich, shared inheritance, ours by natural right as a Briton.
Whatever is English is part of a Scot's inheritance and whatever is Scottish is the inheritance of an Englishman.
This sense of identity can only be enriching for us all. This shared inheritance is available within the identity of Britishness but it is not available to those who identify only with one area of our island archipelago.
Our history in the British Isles is an amazing history of people, settlement, achievements, challenges, struggles. We are all heir to this remarkable history regardless from where in the British Isles we hail. If we only identify with one area of our Islands then we cannot feel part of that inheritance - and intellectually and spiritually, that will impoverish us.
7- It is Great to be British because Britain was our original country.
Long before there was an "England" or a "Scotland" and long before warring tribes separated Britain up into the arbitrary boundaries we have today...there was "Britain", our nation! One of the earliest references to our country is by Virgil (70-19BC) in his reference in Eclogue I to the land, "Where the Briton dwells, utterly estranged from all the world."
8- It is Great to be British because together we can accomplish more.
Like a man and woman, who marry, we "Don't have to pull in single harness all our lives." We're stronger together and the tasks which face us can be better solved by a people united.
9- It is Great to be British because Britain is greater than the sum of its parts.
Again, like a married man and woman, this has long been observed. For example, in 1603, 33 years after being crowned King of Scotland, James VI became James I of Great Britain. His vision was one of British unity:
Doe wee not remember, that this Kingdome [England] was divided into seven little Kingdomes, besides Wales? And is it not now the stronger by their Union? And hath not the Union of
Wales to England added a greater Strength therto?...I desire a perfect Union of Lawes and Persons, and such a Naturalizing as may make one Body of both Kingdomes under mee your King. That I and my Posteritie (if it so please God) may rule over you to the Worlds End;1
We also point out to those who imagine the idea of Britain is "a recent modern invention" that James I liked to be styled "King of Great Britain"2 and indeed the King James Bible, first published in 1611, states on its very first page:
James by the Grace of God
King of Great Britain, France, and Ireland
Defender of the Faith.
10- It is Great to be British because it prevents tiresome quarrelling and unnecessary conflict as a result of different identities.
A lot of the separatist case for the so-called "independence" of Scotland from England is frankly, unnecessary, unrealistic, unworkable and unwanted.
The blunt truth of the matter is that there are no major national differences or interests between Scotland and England and its peoples, which require "independence" for Scotland from England in order to deal with those differences or interests.
The separatists imagine Britain to be a temporary arrangement with an inevitable fate of separation. They are wrong. It is more sensible and more correct to see Britain as a natural and evolving organism tending towards unity.
We emphasise unity, not division - what we have in common, not what divides us. We say that a vision of a united Britain is more inspiring in its appeal than that of a separated Scotland!
To summarise: It is great to be British because it is great to identify with, and to be loyal to, the nation of Britain, and its people - all those of us who possess and share in common, a particular history, an inheritance, a set of cultural traditions, and a distinct set of national icons and institutions.
It is great to value all of this and to want to see these elements supported, secured, strengthened, esteemed and promoted at home and abroad.
It is great to emphasise the spiritual, intellectual and physical bonds which exist in our islands, and to emphasise the inclusive British identity which we can all share, instead of the artificial differences constructed by the politics of the day.
Our destiny is bound intimately with our fellows throughout these islands. It is foolish to divide ourselves wilfully against each other.
So let us be united in spirit: A community of people standing together and sharing naturally in each other's achievements and joy and in that regard, let us remember the immortal words of Robert Burns3:
Be Britain still to Britain true,
Amang oursel's united;
For never but by British hands
Must British wrangs be righted.
(1) Nick Groom, The Union Jack: The Story of the British Flag, (London: Atlantic Books, 2006), at page 125.
(2) He issued a Royal Proclamation to that effect on 20 October 1604. See S.T. Bindoff, "The Stuarts and their Style", The English Historical Review, Volume LX, May 1945, 192-216 at 196.
(3) Does Haughty Gaul Invasion Threat?
|TEN LITTLE KINGDOMS
This poem has circulated for at least 12 years now, and it is claimed to have been "written by Miss J.E. Clarke of Eynsham, and published originally in the 28th August 1889 edition of Judy, the Victorian magazine for girls."
We don't know if that is really the case or not, but it is a very appropriate poem!
Plans for separation grew worse than those before,
Then they asked for two Parliaments, now 'tis three or four.
Only just imagine if Home Rulers had their way,
This is something like the tale the world might hear one day:
One United Kingdom they fancied wouldn't do.
To please some grumbling Irish they split it into two.
Two little Kingdoms, but then the Scots, you see,
Claimed their ancient throne and rights, and then there were three.
Three little Kingdoms, and after that one more;
For Welshmen claimed a parliament, and then there were four.
Four little Kingdoms wouldn't do at all -
One of them was far too big; the others far too small.
All throughout Great Britain ancient hates revived,
Cornwall wants to rule herself, and then there were five.
Five little Kingdoms, but London in a fix,
Raised the "Southern English" flag, and then there were six!
Six little Kingdoms, alas! the "Home Rule" leaven
Caused a rising in the West, and then there were seven!
Seven little Kingdoms; Northmen wouldn't wait,
But started the Northumbrian state, and then there were eight.
And all the towns one may visit by the Eastern Counties line,
Held their own East Anglian Parliament, and then there were nine.
Nine little Kingdoms; the Midlands people then
Called a parliament themselves, and then there were ten!
Ten little Kingdoms never could agree
How to work together, and so they went free.
Ten little Kingdoms with constitutions new,
Ten little Kingdoms always in a stew,
Ten little Kingdoms too weak to stand alone,
A foreign nation conquered them - and then there were none!